+1 888 931 0363

Inquire Request a quote

Sunset Key Cottages

A private-island resort on a 27-acre island off Old Town Key West, reachable by launch in minutes, with 40 standalone cottages (one to four bedrooms with full kitchens), the celebrated Latitudes waterfront restaurant, the Opal Spa, a private white-sand beach, and a lagoon-style heated pool.

At Do Not Disturb, we match you with one of our dedicated luxury travel experts who designs a tailor-made itinerary around how you want your time away to feel. With deep destination knowledge and meticulous planning behind the scenes, we transform complex travel into something effortless and entirely your own.

The world without distraction.

Inquire

At a glance

Sunset Key Cottages is a private-island resort a few minutes by launch off Old Town Key West.

Sunset Key is a 27-acre private island about 500 yards off Mallory Square. The crossing takes minutes, but the island feels a world away. 40 standalone cottages, from one to four bedrooms, with tin roofs, wraparound porches, and full kitchens; the largest hold private plunge pools.

Latitudes, the island’s waterfront restaurant, is one of Key West’s most sought-after dinner reservations, especially at sunset, with a pool bar for the daytime. The Opal Spa handles massages and facials, and there is a lagoon-style heated pool, a private white-sand beach with cabanas, and tennis courts. The multi-bedroom cottages work for couples, families, and groups, and it is pet-friendly. Old Town, with Duval Street and the Hemingway Home, is a short launch ride away.

Plan Your Trip

In detail

Food and Drink

Latitudes is the island’s restaurant, and one of the best-known tables in Key West, set on the water for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Sunset is the prized slot, and reservations are worth booking weeks ahead.

Flippers, the pool bar, handles casual daytime food and drinks, and a Rise and Dine breakfast basket can be delivered to the cottage. With full kitchens in every cottage and a resort grocery service, guests can also self-cater.
Spa and Wellness

The Opal Spa at Sunset Key offers massages, facials, and body treatments in a quiet setting on the island.

The real draw is the water: a lagoon-style heated pool, a private crescent of white-sand beach with cabanas, and beach yoga in the mornings. Tennis courts and a fitness center sit alongside, with fishing direct from the dock. With no cars and few day-trippers, the island stays calm in a way Key West itself rarely is.
Location

Sunset Key is a private island about 500 yards off Old Town Key West, reached by the resort’s launch, which crosses to and from the marina at Opal Key roughly every half hour.

That puts the whole of Old Town within easy reach: Duval Street’s bars and restaurants, Mallory Square’s sunset celebration, the Hemingway Home, and the Southernmost Point are all a short ride and a walk away. Key West International Airport is about 15 minutes from the dock.

Plan Your Trip

Room Types

One Bedroom Garden View Cottage

A wraparound veranda and an outdoor dining area, suited to the Rise and Dine breakfast delivered to the door each morning.

A living and dining room with a large dining table. Each cottage holds either a full or en-suite bathroom.

Plan Your Journey

Luxury Three Bedroom Ocean Front Cottage

1,700 square feet of space with uninterrupted ocean views in every direction.

A spacious living area and full kitchen, with breakfast delivered to the door each morning. One of the most generous configurations on the island.

Request a Quote

Luxury Three Bedroom Ocean Front Cottage

Four Bedroom Ocean Front Cottage

2,500 square feet of space with a private plunge pool and beach area. One bedroom on the first floor, two upstairs with shared bathrooms, and a master suite with a private balcony and a jacuzzi tub.

The natural choice for families or groups taking the island as a base. Other cottage configurations are available on request.

Speak With an Expert

Our reviews

“Our trip was truly magical and full of core memories that will last us a lifetime.”

Michael • Bora Bora Honeymoon

“We just returned from an incredible journey through Ireland, and we couldn’t have had a better experience”

Brad • Ireland Adventure

“This was a flawless experience. They took all our thoughts and perfectly curated the most beautiful honeymoon.”

Kris • Sicily Honeymoon

Our team brings over 35 years of experience in luxury travel, shaping bespoke journeys for discerning clients worldwide. The reviews below reflect the trust placed in us and the experiences we continue to create.

See more reviews on Trustpilot

Travel inspiration and editorials

5 min read

Is Amangiri America’s Most Extraordinary Hotel?

The desert resort in southern Utah has been called many things since it opened in 2009. After a few days in the canyon country, the superlatives start to feel earned.

5 min read

The New American Riviera: Where the US Does Coastal Luxury Best

Discover the New American Riviera, from Montecito to Nantucket and the Hamptons.

4 min read

America’s Best Wine Regions (That Aren’t Napa)

Napa still sets the benchmark for American wine travel, but it is far from the only place doing it well. Across the US, a handful of regions have built serious reputations for specific grapes, distinct climates, and style of hospitality.

Wilderness to Waves: Luxury Honeymoons in Kenya

Kenya’s most compelling honeymoon itinerary moves between two entirely different worlds: the wildlife-dense plains of the Maasai Mara and the ancient coral-stone quietude of Lamu Island. Together, they form a journey that is both dramatically varied and precisely calibrated for couples seeking depth over spectacle.

Your next steps

Planning your trip should feel effortless.

We Listen

You share what matters, whether it’s a destination, a feeling, or a moment worth celebrating.

We Curate

Your dedicated expert shapes a thoughtful, private itinerary tailored entirely around you.

You Travel

Every detail handled. Every moment considered. Support before, during, and after your journey.

Tell us about your journey

Budget per person

$2,000–3,000 $3,000–5,000 $5,000–7,500 $7,500–10,000 $10,000+

Step 1 / 2

Please leave this field empty.